Watchdog Nation

Guide to Saving on Your Electricity Bill

By Dave Lieber

For me, the good news about Texas electricity is that I have used five different power companies in the last five years and not once has the power gone out for any reason other than bad weather.

Uninterrupted power. That’s about the only good thing I can say.

Otherwise, it’s all bad. Costs are too high. Companies offer such confusing rates and service plans that many Texas consumers feel like victims of bait-and-switch schemes. And those whose electrical provider went bust found themselves slammed into high-cost plans.

The Texas Legislature started this mess in 1999, when it passed a law deregulating the electricity marketplace. Until recent months, Texans were paying some of the highest electricity rates in the nation.

State lawmakers met again in 2009 and did not pass legislation that would have made some of the shady marketing practices illegal. Fortunately, the Texas Public Utility Commission issued some new pro-consumer pricing rules that went into in May 2009. Shopping for an electricity contract is now simpler and fairer than before. Click here to read the new rules.

Why should you care? Answer: as I originally shared exclusively with readers of the Fort Worth Star-Telegram – one of Texas’ finest newspapers – you can save hundreds of dollars a year. When it comes to making your family’s decision about which power company to choose, you have to be your own watchdog. Sometime in 2010, when your current contract is set to expire, you will have to make major decisions:

Will you stay with your current company or switch to an unknown? Should you extend the contract for a year, a half-year, three months or go month-to-month? What about a fixed rate versus a variable rate?

Here’s The Watchdog’s gift to you – The 2010 Guide to Picking the Best Electricity Provider:

  1. TXU no longer rules. Get over the idea that TXU Energy, most likely your original provider, is the only company that can offer solid, uninterrupted service. And don’t believe the fallacy that TXU customers get serviced first when power goes out.
  2. Oncor Electric Delivery is responsible for maintaining the transmission system. Everybody, TXU and its many competitors, uses them to handle repairs.
  3. Switching is good. Act under the assumption that you should switch companies every year. The market is constantly changing.
  4. You can find better deals and save hundreds of dollars a year, maybe even more, with this one decision. Electricity is measured by kWh, or kilowatts per hour. If you pay 10 cents a kWh instead of 14 cents, your monthly electric bill could be $100 or more lower.
  5. Know your current contract terms. Before you can shop, know what you have. Do you know your kWh rate? It’s on your electric bill, and it might be higher than what’s available now. (In Texas, it ranges from 8 cents to as high as 25 cents.) Also call your provider and ask for the date when your contract expires. Find out, if you don’t know, whether your rate is fixed or variable. Start planning a possible switch two months before a contract expires.
  6. Decide whether you want to play it safe or be a gambler. Do you want to lock in a fixed rate that you can afford for a longer period of time? Or are you willing to take a low price now and understand that a variable rate could spike depending on market conditions?
  7. Conduct a thorough search. Go to this Web site: www.powertochoose.org. (If you don’t have an Internet connection, visit your public library and ask your librarian for help. Or ask a friend or relative to help you.) Click on “Go Directly to Offers”, and then enter your zip code. Also, check the company’s own Web site. Sometimes the company’s price might be cheaper than powertochoose.org
  8. Pick your poison. In the left-side column, under “Rate Type,” pick either fixed or variable. (The Watchdog likes fixed since current market conditions are too volatile.) Under “Price,” type in a range of from 7 cents to 14 cents. That’s a good spread. Then hit submit.
  9. Study the results. For the selection cited above, about a dozen companies last week offered rates between 8.9 cents per kWh and 13 cents. Contract lengths varied between three and 24 months. Each service plan comes with links to “Terms of Service,” “Facts Label,” “Signup” and “Special Terms.” When you click on these, you learn the nitty-gritty details.
  10. Check out your favorite. After you find a company with a rate and contract length you like, learn more about them. Return to the original page, www.powertochoose.org, and click on “Customer Complaint Statistics.” The link marked “Residential Retail Electric Provider Complaint Scorecard” leads you to a state scorecard showing complaint ratings for a six-month period based on a four-star system, similar to movie ratings. Except, here, you don’t want four stars. Another link on the home page, called “REP Complaint Summary,” shows you what the complaints were about.
  11. Check out other sources. If the company comes out good enough on complaints, dig a little deeper. What are angry customers saying about this company? To find out, use an Internet search engine this way: Put the name of the company in between quote marks and then follow it with the word “ripoff.” Do the same with the word “scam.” If only a few results come up from disgruntled customers, don’t worry. But if there are several dozen, do a search for the company’s name and “Better Business Bureau.” You’ll be able to pull up the company’s report in the BBB region of its headquarters.

Final switch tips. When you make your final selection, don’t call your current electricity provider to cancel. That could cause problems. Sign up with the new company, and it will handle the transfer. Try to sign up at least four to six weeks before your plan expires so the overlap between the two billing cycles is negligible. Some people switch too late and pay higher prices during the transition.

Remember, there’s no loss of power when you switch. It happens, and you don’t even know it.

Until the bill comes.

Share and Print:
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • PDF
  • StumbleUpon
  • Print

Published in Utilities, February 1st, 2010 by Dave Lieber

Tags: , , ,

15 Comments to this post.

  1. djw djw

    If your old agreement is at a higher rate, or you risk going to the old company’s “default” rate (which is usually very high), ask your new company for an off-cycle meter reading to get the switched more quickly. This typically costs around $8 but can save a cycle or two being ripped-off.

  2. Mike S Mike S

    I just switched to Champion as of today, 9.3 cts per KWH with 4.95 monthly charge. I did an off-cyle meter read for $8-9. I left Direct Energy and I do not recommend DE at all! Champion has one of the best scorecard ratings per the PUC.

  3. watchdog Dave Lieber

    That’s impressive, Mike, that you matched up the financial cost with the scorecard ratings. That’s how the electrical guide says to do it! Way 2 go.

  4. Robert Menard Robert Menard

    Dave, I am confused. Do you have a recommendation for power supplier?

  5. watchdog Dave Lieber

    I do not and here’s why: About four companies went out of business in Texas last year, causing terrible hardship for those customers, who are thrown into what is called the POLR pool (Provider of Last Resort). These folks were paying 15 or 16 cents with National Power and suddenly they were paying 25 cents a kWh with Amigo Energy. Not good! So let’s assume that one or more companies will close again this year. How are we to know who is in trouble? If I recommend Company XYZ to you and they close, wow would you be mad?? Or what?? So you must take responsibility. I try to provide members of Watchdog Nation with the tool to know how to choose. But what I suggest in my guide is you check their complaint rate, and go with the leap of faith that a company with a high complaint rate is in some kind of trouble.

  6. Harry Harry

    What about commercial accounts with demand charges. Are the demand charges passed directly on by Oncor? If so, are these demand charges the same with every provider or do they add additional percentages on to what is billed to them by Oncor? Not sure if the regulations allow such practices?

  7. watchdog Dave Lieber

    The demand charges are levied by the retail providers on businesses. This is the most complicated issue I’ve ever covered in Texas. When I did a story on demand fees a year ago, even the TXU folks couldn’t explain it in a way that anyone understands. This issue is so difficult that I would suggest if you have these questions, you go straight to the PUC. If you have trouble getting anyone, let me know and I will contact them on your behalf.

  8. Customer Service « Two Cents At A Time Customer Service « Two Cents At A Time

    [...] contacted me. This is annoying, but it will be eventually resolved, and thanks Dave, I will take your advice and change electric companies. (That’s a great essay, be sure to bookmark it because [...]

  9. The Company I Keep « Two Cents At A Time The Company I Keep « Two Cents At A Time

    [...] (Sometimes you get on a roll, and decide to take on all of them!) So first thing I did was go to Dave Lieber’s Watchdog Nation site and re-read his articles about saving money by changing electric companies, information I will [...]

  10. Jim W Jim W

    Dave, when going through all the information under power to choose, I see there are
    many, many more complaints about TXU than there are about other companies, for example Reliant Energy. Is it safe to assume that is because TXU
    serves a whole lot more customers than the other providers, or is that not a
    reasonable assumption? I looked at my bill to see it is .1233 per kwh…..I figured the
    difference to go to a company charging 10.9c per kwh….and it’s only about $8 based
    on my usage in December (475 kwh)….Is it worth it?

  11. SW Arlington SW Arlington

    Dave,

    Is there any way to take advantage of the promotional rates of these companies by switching providers every month?

    SW Arlington

  12. watchdog Dave Lieber

    I don’t think it would be worth all the trouble it would cause in your life. Plus, there’s a 45-day switch that would mess things up for you pretty good.

  13. watchdog Dave Lieber

    Yes, you are right. With more customers, they would have a ratio of more complaints that should not reflect poorly on them. (But if you talk to their disgruntled customers, maybe it should!)
    12.3 is good, but if you can get a niner, you should consider it.

  14. Lynne T Lynne T

    Have you ever had success or heard of others having success asking TXU to match a competitor’s rate? I currently have 10.99 for the first 126 KWH and 12.33 for the next level of usage with TXU. Is it worth a call to see if they would match the lower rates offered by competitors, even if it means I have to sign a contract?

    Also, if you’ve had service with TXU for many years as I have, how can I have a contract unless it is a month to month? I have never signed anything or agreed to anything since I started service years ago. And I actually read everything they send me. There has never been any mention of a new contract, etc.

  15. watchdog Dave Lieber

    You definitely have nothing to lose by calling and asking TXU to bargain with you. In fact, it’s the natural next step. If you sign a contract, make sure the rate is in the 9’s or 10s, though.

    About your "contract:" They slide you into various plans. Many people don’t know how they got in the plan they are in. They didn’t understand the choices. They bought it from a door-to-door guy (WORST way to buy electricity) or from a heavy-handed phone solicitor. You have to ask them specifically what you have and then go look it up for more information. Every plan has a "Terms of Service" which tells you exactly what you are getting. It’s the legal document. And also a basic label that gives you the barebones.

Leave a Reply